Short Answer
The biggest savings come from three things: turning the heat down when you’re asleep or out, stopping the drafts that let warm air leak out, and keeping the furnace filter clean so the system isn’t working harder than it has to. After that, small habits add up: open the curtains on sunny days, close them at night, run ceiling fans clockwise on low, and set the water heater to 120°F. Most of this costs little or nothing and you can do it this weekend.
This box contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See the affiliate note at the bottom of this post.
🛒 Helpful Picks
The caulk is the one I use on the job. The rest are well-reviewed options to compare, not specific products I’m vouching for.
- The caulk I use for gaps around trim and baseboards
- Furnace filter multipacks so you always have the next one on hand (check your filter’s size first)
- Door sweeps for the gap under an exterior door
- Foam outlet and switch gaskets for outlets on outside walls
A Cleveland winter is long, and the gas bill shows it. You can’t control the price of gas, but you can control how much heat your house throws away. Heating and cooling is close to half of a typical home’s energy bill, according to ENERGY STAR, so it’s the first place to look.
Here’s what I’d do, in order, starting with the free stuff.
1. Turn the Heat Down When You Don’t Need It
This is the biggest free win. A furnace works harder the bigger the gap between inside and outside, so every hour the house sits a few degrees cooler is gas you didn’t burn. The Department of Energy says you can save as much as 10% a year by turning the thermostat back 7 to 10 degrees for 8 hours a day, like while you sleep or while everyone’s at work.
- Pick a comfortable daytime setting and stick to it. Every degree higher costs more.
- Set it back at night and when you’re out. A programmable or smart thermostat does this for you, so you don’t have to remember.
- Don’t go too low in a cold snap. If you’re leaving for a few days, keep it warm enough that pipes on outside walls don’t freeze.
- Heat pumps are different. Big setbacks can kick on the expensive backup heat, so use smaller ones.
I go through settings, vacation mode and heat pumps in thermostat settings for Ohio winters and summers.
2. Stop the Drafts
Warm air leaking out means cold air leaking in somewhere else. ENERGY STAR estimates that sealing air leaks and adding insulation in the attic, crawl space and basement saves an average of 15% on heating and cooling costs. The air sealing part is mostly a caulk gun and an afternoon.
Start by finding the leaks. On a cold, windy day, feel around windows, doors, outlets on outside walls, and where pipes and wires come through walls. How to check your home for drafts walks through it. Then fix what you find:
- Windows: lock them, caulk the trim, and weatherstrip the sashes. Rope caulk or shrink film gets an old window through the winter. Full steps are in how to seal drafty windows for winter.
- Exterior doors: if you can see daylight around the door, replace the weatherstripping and add or adjust the door sweep. See how to install weatherstripping on a door.
- Outlets and switches on outside walls: foam gaskets behind the cover plates take a few minutes each. Turn off the breaker before you take the cover off.
- Gaps around pipes and wires under sinks and in the basement: caulk small gaps, and use expanding foam for bigger ones.
- The fireplace: if you’re not using it, close the damper. An open damper is basically an open window up the chimney.
3. Keep the Furnace Breathing
A dirty filter makes the blower work harder and can make the furnace run longer to heat the house. DOE says to check the filter every month and replace it when it’s dirty, at least every three months. If you have pets, a dusty house or you’re doing a renovation, it’ll likely need changing sooner.
Write the filter size on the side of the furnace with a marker so you buy the right one every time. Step by step is in how to clean and replace furnace filters. Also keep the supply and return vents clear of furniture, rugs and curtains, and don’t close off too many vents in unused rooms; that can make the system work harder, not less.
A yearly furnace tune-up by an HVAC tech is worth it too, both for efficiency and safety. If yours hasn’t had one, when to start using your furnace and how to prepare it covers what to check.
4. Use the Sun and Your Curtains
ENERGY STAR’s advice for cold weather is simple: open the drapes during the day to let the sun in, and close them at night to hold the heat. South-facing windows do the most work on a sunny day. Heavy curtains or cellular shades help the most on older windows. If you’re adding them, start with how to measure for blinds and curtains.
5. Run Ceiling Fans Clockwise on Low
Warm air rises and sits at the ceiling. DOE recommends running the fan clockwise at low speed in winter to push that warm air down. It won’t change the temperature in the room, but you’ll feel warmer at the same setting. Turn the fan off when nobody’s in the room. More on fan direction is in which direction your ceiling fan should go.
6. Turn the Water Heater Down
ENERGY STAR says most water heaters are set at 140°F, which wastes energy keeping the tank hot and can scald. Setting it to 120°F is enough for most households. On a gas tank water heater, it’s usually a dial on the gas valve near the bottom of the tank. Follow the label on your unit, and if anything about it looks wrong or smells like gas, stop and call a pro.
7. Watch the Humidity
Dry air feels colder, so you may turn the heat up when the house is actually warm enough. A cheap hygrometer tells you where you are. Keep it in the healthy range rather than cranking a humidifier, or your windows will drip. I cover the right range in humidity in winter: do you need a humidifier?
Bigger Fixes Worth Planning
These cost real money, so they’re for after the free and cheap stuff:
- Attic insulation and air sealing. Often the best payback in an older East Side house. See improving energy efficiency with insulation.
- Storm windows or replacement windows when the old ones are past saving. Storm windows and storm doors: are they still worth it?
- A newer furnace or heat pump when yours is old and needs repairs. That’s an HVAC contractor’s call.
Time, Cost and Difficulty
- Difficulty: easy for everything in steps 1 to 7.
- Time: a weekend afternoon for the drafts and filter. The thermostat, curtains, fans and water heater take minutes.
- Tools: caulk gun, putty knife, screwdriver, flashlight and a marker for the furnace.
Common Mistakes
- Cranking the thermostat way up to heat the house faster. Most furnaces heat at the same rate no matter how high you set it.
- Using the oven or a gas stove to heat the house. It’s a fire and carbon monoxide risk.
- Running a space heater on an extension cord. Plug it straight into the wall, keep it 3 feet from anything that can burn, and turn it off when you leave the room.
- Sealing up the house and forgetting the CO detector. A tighter house with a gas furnace needs a working carbon monoxide alarm on every level. See my winter carbon monoxide safety guide.
- Blocking vents or the furnace’s air intake with boxes or storage.
DIY or Call a Guy?
DIY it: thermostat setbacks, curtains, ceiling fans, furnace filters, outlet gaskets and most caulking and weatherstripping. These are the cheapest savings you’ll find.
Call a guy: when there’s a whole house of windows and doors to seal, exterior caulking off a ladder, or doors that need adjusting before the weatherstripping will seal. Call a licensed HVAC tech for furnace tune-ups, any gas smell, or a furnace that short-cycles or won’t keep up, and an insulation contractor for the attic.
Local to Euclid or Cleveland’s east side? I caulk windows and trim, put on weatherstripping and door sweeps, and adjust doors that won’t seal myself. See my Caulking in Euclid & Cleveland page or my Handyman Time Blocks to knock out a list of drafty windows and doors at once, or text me a photo at 216-800-5883.
FAQ
What’s the single best way to lower my heating bill?
Turn the thermostat back at night and when you’re away. DOE says 7 to 10 degrees for 8 hours a day can save up to 10% a year, and it costs nothing.
Is it cheaper to leave the heat at one temperature all day?
For a gas furnace, no. Setting it back saves energy because the house loses heat more slowly when it’s cooler. Heat pumps are the exception: keep setbacks small so the backup heat doesn’t kick on.
Does closing vents in unused rooms save money?
Usually not much, and closing too many can make the system work harder. Close the door and leave the vent open instead.
How often should I change my furnace filter in winter?
Check it monthly and replace it when it’s dirty, at least every three months.
Are space heaters cheaper than the furnace?
Only if you’re heating one small room and turning the furnace down. Heating a whole house with electric space heaters usually costs more, and they need to be used carefully.
Related Guides
- Thermostat settings for Ohio winters and summers
- How to seal drafty windows for winter
- Humidity in winter: do you need a humidifier?
- How to check your home for drafts
- How to install weatherstripping on a door
- How to clean and replace furnace filters
Sources
- U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Saver: Thermostats
- U.S. Department of Energy: 5 Tips to Help You Save on Energy Bills This Winter
- ENERGY STAR: How to Save Energy at Home

Scan to join our Loyalty Program, get a free coupon for your next service, and stay up to date on our services and articles.
Affiliate Note
Some of the links in this article are affiliate links. That simply means if you choose to buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. I only recommend products I trust and would feel comfortable installing in my own home or a client’s home.
If you try something I recommended and it turns out to be anything less than a five-star experience, please let me know. I always want these recommendations to be genuinely helpful.
