Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams are two of the most trusted paint brands, offering high-quality products with differences in pricing, availability, color options, and application. Sherwin-Williams is often preferred for its durability, ease of access, and professional appeal, while Benjamin Moore stands out for its color technology and eco-friendliness. Both brands offer a wide range of finishes and styles, making them suitable for different project needs.
Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin-Williams: A Complete Breakdown
1. Brand Overview
- Sherwin-Williams: A globally recognized name with over 150 years of history. Its paints are widely used by contractors and professionals due to their durability and performance, with a focus on accessibility through dedicated Sherwin-Williams stores.
- Benjamin Moore: A similarly longstanding brand with a reputation for innovation, particularly in its eco-friendly offerings and advanced color-matching technology. It’s sold through independent retailers, allowing a more personalized shopping experience.
2. Price Points
- Sherwin-Williams: Generally more affordable, especially during their frequent sales and promotions. Ideal for those managing larger projects or looking to stretch their budget.
- Benjamin Moore: Typically priced higher, reflecting its emphasis on premium ingredients and color consistency. Appeals to homeowners seeking long-lasting finishes and rich, true colors.
3. Color Selection
- Sherwin-Williams: Offers over 1,700 colors, with tools like the ColorSnap® Visualizer that make it easier to select shades. Their colors are optimized for versatile projects and lighting conditions.
- Benjamin Moore: Renowned for its depth of color, including its proprietary Gennex® waterborne colorant technology. Colors like those in the Aura® and Regal® Select lines are prized for their richness and subtle undertones.
4. Availability
- Sherwin-Williams: Found in Sherwin-Williams-owned stores, which ensures consistent stock and access to their full line. More accessible for contractors and frequent buyers.
- Benjamin Moore: Sold exclusively through independent dealers. While this may mean fewer locations, these retailers often provide expert advice tailored to your project.
5. Eco-Friendliness
- Sherwin-Williams: Features low-VOC (volatile organic compound) paints like Harmony® and SuperPaint®, with a focus on reducing indoor air pollutants.
- Benjamin Moore: Leads the charge in eco-friendly paints with products like Natura® (discontinued but replaced by newer green lines) and Regal® Select, known for being zero-VOC even after tinting.
6. Paint Performance and Application
- Sherwin-Williams: Known for ease of application and durability, with a slight edge in exterior paint performance. Lines like Emerald® and Duration® are ideal for high-traffic areas or outdoor projects.
- Benjamin Moore: Offers superior coverage with fewer coats, particularly in premium lines like Aura®. Their paints are also noted for smoother finishes and excellent adherence.
7. Customer and Professional Preference
- Sherwin-Williams: Often favored by professionals for its consistency and availability. Contractors appreciate the dedicated customer support, rewards programs, and trade discounts.
- Benjamin Moore: Appeals more to homeowners and designers due to its high-end feel and exclusive distribution model.
8. Durability and Maintenance
- Sherwin-Williams: Excels in long-term durability, particularly for exterior applications. Its paints are highly resistant to weathering, fading, and peeling.
- Benjamin Moore: Offers similar durability, with a focus on smooth finishes and washability. Interior options like Scuff-X® are popular for their resistance to wear and tear.
Final Thoughts for Customers
At Colin Can Help, we understand why Sherwin-Williams might be your top pick—it’s a durable, accessible, and cost-effective solution for most projects. However, for customers who prioritize eco-friendliness or a broader palette of sophisticated colors, Benjamin Moore may be worth the investment. Either way, both brands guarantee professional-quality results, so the choice comes down to personal preferences, project needs, and budget.
Affiliate Note
Some of the links in this article may be affiliate links. That simply means if you choose to buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I trust and would feel comfortable installing in my own home or a client’s home.
If you try something I recommended and it turns out to be anything less than a five-star experience, please let me know. I always want these recommendations to be genuinely helpful.