DIYHandymanNovember 18, 2026by Colin

How to Replace an Interior Door (Slab vs Prehung)

Short Answer

If the frame is straight and in good shape and you only need a new door, buy a slab and fit it to the old opening. If the frame is beat up, out of square, or you’re changing the door size, buy a prehung door, which comes already hung in its own frame. A slab costs less but takes more careful work (trimming, hinge mortises, boring for the knob). A prehung door is more demolition, but it’s the easier way to get a door that swings and latches right.

This box contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See the affiliate note at the bottom of this post.

🧰 What You’ll Need

What I Use:

2-foot level
The whole job comes down to getting the hinge jamb plumb. A 2-foot level is easy to hold against the jamb, and I check it on both faces.
Check price →
Drill bit set
For pilot holes in the hinge screws and the strike plate, so the screws don’t split the jamb.
Check price →

Helpful Picks: these are well-reviewed options, not my personal picks.

Slab vs. Prehung: What’s the Difference?

A slab is just the door. No hinges, no frame, usually no holes for the knob. You fit it into the frame you already have.

A prehung door is a door already hung on hinges inside its own frame (the jambs), usually with the stop attached. You pull out the old door and frame and set the whole unit into the rough opening in the wall.

Pick a slab when

  • The old frame is solid, square, and the old door closed fine before it got damaged.
  • You want to keep the existing casing and paint around the door.
  • The opening is an odd size. Older houses don’t always have today’s standard sizes, and a slab can be trimmed to fit an opening a prehung unit won’t.

Pick a prehung door when

  • The jamb is split, chewed up by old hinge repairs, or out of plumb.
  • You’re changing the door’s width or the direction it swings.
  • You don’t have the tools or patience for hinge mortises and boring a lockset hole. A prehung door has all of that done at the factory.
  • You’re doing new trim anyway, since the casing has to come off for a prehung install.

How to Measure

For a slab

Measure the old door, not the opening: width, height, and thickness. Most newer interior doors are 80 inches tall and 1-3/8 inches thick, but older doors can be anything, so measure. Note where the hinges sit and how many there are, and whether the knob hole is in good shape. Many people buy a slab a bit oversized and trim it down to match the old door.

For a prehung door

Prehung doors are sold by the size of the door (a “30-inch door”), but what has to fit is the frame. Take the casing off one side so you can see the framing, then measure:

  • Rough opening width: stud to stud at the top, middle, and bottom. Use the smallest number.
  • Rough opening height: from the finished floor to the underside of the header, at both sides and the middle. Use the smallest.
  • Jamb width: the wall thickness, from drywall face to drywall face. Masonite lists 4-9/16″, 5-1/4″ and 6-9/16″ as common jamb widths. Plaster walls in older homes are often thicker than drywall, so measure instead of assuming.

The rough opening is usually around 2 inches wider and a bit over 2 inches taller than the door itself, but check the spec sheet for the unit you’re buying. Masonite has a good page on measuring for an interior door.

Handing

This trips people up more than anything. Stand in the doorway with your back against the hinge side and the door opening toward you. If the knob is on your right, it’s a right-hand door; on your left, it’s a left-hand door. Get this wrong on a prehung unit and you’re making a return trip.

How to Hang a Slab in an Existing Frame

  1. Pull the old door. Tap the hinge pins up from the bottom, starting with the bottom hinge, and lift the door off.
  2. Trace it. Lay the old door on the new slab with the tops and the latch edges lined up. Trace the outline and transfer the hinge locations with a square.
  3. Trim. Score the line with a utility knife so the veneer doesn’t splinter, then cut with a circular saw and a straightedge. If you’re taking off more than an inch of height, split it between the top and bottom. Hollow-core doors have a solid block at the top and bottom, so don’t cut so much that you cut it away.
  4. Cut the hinge mortises. Chisel each one as deep as the hinge leaf is thick, so the leaf sits flush with the edge. Too deep and the door binds on the hinge side; a thin cardboard shim behind the leaf fixes that.
  5. Bore for the lockset. Use the template that comes with the knob. Most use a 2-1/8″ hole through the face and a 7/8″ hole into the edge for the latch. A lock installation kit with a jig makes this a lot more forgiving.
  6. Hang and check the gaps. You’re looking for about 1/8 inch along the sides and top, even all the way around, and enough room at the bottom to clear the flooring or carpet. Bend the strike plate tab slightly if the door rattles when it’s closed.

This Old House walks through the same process with photos in how to replace an interior door.

How to Install a Prehung Door

  1. Remove the casing, then the old door and jambs. Cut the paint line between the casing and the wall with a utility knife first so you don’t tear the drywall. If the house was built before 1978, test the old paint for lead before you pry, cut, or sand painted trim. The EPA’s lead-safe page for do-it-yourselfers covers what to do.
  2. Dry fit. Set the unit in the opening, centered, with the jambs flush with both wall faces. Leave the shipping clips or nails in until the hinge side is set.
  3. Plumb the hinge side. This is the step that decides everything. Shim behind each hinge until the hinge jamb is plumb on both faces, then nail through the jamb and the shims into the stud. Masonite’s prehung install guide calls for two fasteners at each shim spot, about an inch from each edge of the jamb.
  4. Set the latch side by the gap. Pull the shipping clips, close the door, and shim the latch jamb until the gap along the top and latch side is even and the door swings without rubbing. Then fasten it.
  5. Snug it up. Many installers swap one screw in the top hinge for a long screw that reaches the stud, which keeps a heavier door from sagging. Score the shims with a utility knife and snap them off flush.
  6. Casing and hardware. Nail the casing back on, install the knob and strike, then fill nail holes, caulk the casing to the wall, and paint.

Time and Difficulty

Slab: moderate. Measuring and tracing are easy; clean hinge mortises and a straight lockset bore take care. Figure a few hours for a first-timer, plus paint.

Prehung: moderate. Less fussy cutting, more demo and trim work. Plan on half a day or more for your first one, including casing, before paint. Solid-core doors are heavy, so have a second person for the lift.

Common Mistakes

  • Ordering the wrong handing.
  • Buying a prehung unit with the wrong jamb width, so the casing won’t sit flat on one side.
  • Shimming the latch side first and chasing the gap from the wrong end.
  • Over-tightening shims so the jamb bows and the door rubs in the middle.
  • Trimming a hollow-core slab too much and losing the solid block at the bottom.
  • Forgetting to paint or seal the cut edges, which lets moisture into the door.

DIY or Call a Guy?

DIY it if the frame is in good shape and you’re swapping a slab, or you’re comfortable with a level and want to learn on a prehung closet door first. Closet and bedroom doors are forgiving places to start.

Call someone if the opening is out of square, the walls are old plaster, you’re replacing several doors at once, or you want the doors, casing, and paint done in one go. A door that rubs or won’t latch is often an adjustment, not a replacement, so it’s worth having someone look before you buy anything. Once it’s in, here’s how to paint an interior door, how to paint the trim around it, and how to fix a doorknob hole and add a door stop if the old door punched through the wall. For exterior doors, sealing the gaps is its own job: how to install weatherstripping on a door. Not sure what a handyman can take on? Here’s what a handyman can actually fix.

Local to Euclid or Cleveland’s east side? I replace and adjust interior doors myself. See my Handyman Time Blocks in Euclid & Cleveland page, or text me a photo at 216-800-5883.

📱 Text Colin a Photo

FAQ

Is a slab or prehung door easier to install?
For most people, prehung. The hinges, mortises, and bore holes are done for you. The work is in getting the hinge jamb plumb.

Can I put a prehung door in an old opening?
Yes, if the rough opening is big enough once the old jambs are out and you match the jamb width to your wall thickness. Odd-sized openings in older homes sometimes call for a slab instead.

Which way is a right-hand door?
Stand with your back to the hinge side as the door opens toward you. If the knob is on your right, it’s a right-hand door.

Can I reuse my old hinges?
On a slab, yes, if they’re in good shape and the new door is the same thickness. Matching the hinge size and corner shape to the old mortises saves work.

Why does my new door rub at the top?
Usually the hinge jamb isn’t plumb or the top hinge is loose. A long screw through the top hinge into the stud often pulls it back.

Affiliate Note

Some of the links in this article are affiliate links. That simply means if you choose to buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Colin Can Help LLC, 2026 © All Rights Reserved